Q & A

Written on 05/13/2022
Will Aitchison

From Michigan:
Question: How long can an arbitration decision in one case, be used as a precedent in another similar case within the same agency? For instance, 12 years ago an officer is found to have had sex on duty. Department proposed termination. Arbitrator reduced to a five-day suspension. Same Union, same department. Does that arbitration award hold strength in a current case for a similar discipline or can the whole thing be tried again and receive a different outcome?

Answer: There’s no bright-line answer on how long arbitration decisions involving the same parties are influential in future cases. It’s easier to identify what deprives them of continuing influence – when the parties negotiate a new agreement that changes the underlying rules. In the example you give, that might be the employer successfully negotiating a disciplinary matrix that calls for a higher penalty than that imposed in the past.


Submit questions on public safety labor and employment issues, visit our website at www.LRIS.com. LRIS and Will Aitchison do not provide any legal advice, and users of this Q&A service and the LRIS website should consult with their own lawyer for legal advice. LRIS is a general service that provides information over the Internet. We are not a law firm and our employees are not acting as your attorney. The information contained in the Site is general legal information and should not be construed as legal advice to be applied to any specific factual situation.

The post Q & A appeared first on Labor Relations Information System.